HomeMy WebLinkAboutJune 2019PADUCAH HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
Minutes —June 3, 2019 RECEIVEDAUG _ 6'2019
Meeting Called to Order: 5:06pm CITY CLERK
Roll Call: By Ruthie McCabe, Office Manager — Present:
Chair Shirley Thompson: Commissioners Dann Patterson,
Robert Shy, and Kenneth Hurt Sr.
Quorum: Established at 5:01pm
Invocation: a silent time of prayer
Pledge of Allegiance: Led by Chair Shirley Thompson
Visitors: City Clerk Lindsay Parish; City Manager Jim
Arndt; and Rev. J.W. Cleary, President of NAACP.
The May 6, 2019, minutes were reviewed — a motion to
approve as written by Commissioner Dann Patterson; a
second by Commissioner Kenneth Hurt Sr. — unanimous
approval with no changes.
OLD BUSINESS:
Diversity forum on June 21St, at Walker Hall, starting at
6pm was discussed. The menu is set for 130 people and
130 tickets will be distributed (can only attend with a
ticket). Each Commissioner will have 20 tickets to
distribute, and the other 50 tickets will be for speakers,
their guests, and the public. Chair Thompson handed out
a list of businesses that adhere to diversity standards.
She suggested having different speakers deliver a report
on how their business or organization adheres to and
benefits from diversity. Chair Thompson suggested Pam
Spencer, Paducah's Public relations Officer, introduce the
event. Attorney Adam Futrell, appointed to the Kentucky
Human Rights; Chris Hartman or Robert Courtney from
the Diversity Council of Humana; Someone from US Bank
and possibly someone from the foster care review board.
Commissioner Robert Shy suggested someone from OUT
PADUCAH to speak for LGBTQ.
Commissioner Silverstein was in agreement (by phone)
as Commissioners Patterson, Shy, and Hurt Sr. was; to
have speakers instead of a panel discussion.
Chair Thompson will contact and confirm the speakers.
She is also working on the flyers. The office will contact
Walker Hall on number of tables and the sound system.
City Manager, Jim Arndt, came to the meeting to address
the PHRC proposed ordinance changes and to go over
the existing ordinance line by line to inform the PHRC
exactly what is expected of the commission, because the
existing ordinance is the law in the city of Paducah.
Commissioner Shy asked had the Mayor and City
Commissioners read the proposed new ordinance and
were they going to act on it? City Manager, Jim Arndt,
stated he had met with them and went over it, but they
were not going to do anything with the request.
Commissioner Shy stated he doesn't think the City
Commissioners and Mayor cares about the Human
Rights. City Manager, Jim Arndt, stated there were 40
different Boards in the city and the PHRC is only one of
them, but the PHRC is the only one with an office space
in City Hall and the Mayor and City Commissioners do not
attend any of the 40 Board meetings.
City Manager,. Jim Arndt, had really researched the state
and city Human Rights Ordinances. He was very informed
and helped the PHRC to understand their role to fulfill
the ordinance as written.
Chair Thompson stated the Ky. Human Rights does not
do anything with the complaints that are sent to the
state. It takes a year or more
City Manager, Jim Arndt, stated he and Ruthie in the
PHRC office would have to work together to get the
elected Ky. Officials on board with doing something
about the time on the complaints.
Chair Thompson and the PHR Commissioners feel the
Mayor and City Commissioners made the changes
without ever discussing or getting any imput from the
PHRC, and the Mayor and City Commissioners should get
a legal agreement with the KHR to be more forth coming
with information and the progress on the complaints
sent to them.
City Commissioner Abraham and Mayor Harless with
their proposed Religious Freedom Amendment, was not
discussed with City Manager or anyone. City Manager let
the PHRC know as soon as he knew, which was the day it
was introduced at the City Commission meeting. City
Manager stated he tried to get them to wait on the
amendment, but that did not work out. The amendment
was added to the very end of the PHR ordinance.
Questions were asked on complaints coming into the
office as how to handle them. City Manager, Jim Arndt,
stated to go by the ordinance; and there is a difference
between facilitating a complaint and investigating a
complaint:
Facilitate means to make easier.
Investigate means to observe or inquire into detail. To
make a systematic inquiry or examination.
He stated the PHRC was doing a good job of going by the
ordinance and he is willing to help in any way he could.
NEW BUSINESS:
The June 4, 2019 budget variance report was compared
to the new proposed budget for 2019-2020, beginning
July 1, 2019. The city increased the PHRC budget by
$855.
Reverend J.W. Cleary spoke on the NAACP state
convention being held in Paducah on September 13, 14,
15. They are having a gospel singing on the riverfront on
Friday night, September 13, 2019, and wanted the
Paducah Human Rights to co-sponsor the event with
them. Rev. Cleary is looking at getting Lee Williams and
the QC'S to perform at a cost of $3000. The NAACP is
asking the PHRC to donate $1500 and the county has
committed to donating $1500 to the event. A motion to
co-sponsor and donate $1500 to the event was made by
Commission Dann Patterson; Chair asked for a second
and no second was given. A motion to table was given by
Commissioner Shy, second by Commissioner Hurt Sr.;
unanimous approval to table for further discussion.
The PHRC went into Executive Session at 7:20pm.